Council Should Overturn Hatikvah Variance

Writer says the proposal "violates both negative criteria used for granting the use variance."

Dear Editor,

The East Brunswick Township Council should overturn the use variance granted by the Zoning Board to Hatikvah Charter School that would allow it to relocate to a warehouse in an industrial zone.  The school violates both negative criteria used for granting the use variance.

  1. Will the proposed use impair the intent of the zoning ordinance?   Yes!

The township will lose 55,000 square feet of warehouse space if the school occupies 7 Lexington Court.  The warehouse is located in an area zoned for industrial use owned, until August 2013, by Plumrose USA, a meat manufacturer with production facilities in Mississippi, Indiana, Vermont and Iowa that used the warehouse to distribute its products in our region.  Industrial property generates tax revenues that help relieve the tax burden on EB tax-paying residents.  The township received over $80,000 in tax revenues until the sale to the Eisenrich Family Foundation, which leases the building to “Friends of Hatikvah” which, sub-leases to Hatikvah Charter School.  With this transaction, the township loses annual revenue because public schools are tax exempt. 

    2. Will the proposed use be a detriment to the public good?  Yes!

Locating a public school in an industrial zone threatens child safety.  Trucks and other vehicles move through the zone as activity appropriate to the zone. Trucks use the same routes that school buses and parents would use to drop off and pick up children at the school posing a safety risk to the children.  The industrial park does not have a grassy area for a playground.   Although the school plans to rip up blacktop to create a playground, no soil testing has taken place yet.  Isn’t it possible, indeed likely, that hazardous materials exist in soils of an industrial zone?   Furthermore, the proposed playground will be located adjacent to another tenant where food trucks are repaired.  Although noise, gas fumes, and other environmental insults legally occur in an industrial zone, these are not an appropriate environment for a child’s playground.  Environmental standards differ by intended land use.  Standards for industrial zones are less stringent than for residential, recreational and school zones for obvious reasons.  Regulations applied to this EB industrial zone are appropriate for anticipated industrial use, not designed to protect elementary school children. 

Answers promised by the applicant to a multitude of questions posed by the Zoning Board were not forthcoming. The use variance approved by the Zoning Board has 63 conditions begging the question of how complete the school’s application actually is.  The two-phase approval, requiring the school to come back before the Zoning Board in two years, means that half of the building will remain a warehouse and not undergo renovation or environmental testing until two years after students already occupy the building.  This does nothing to protect the health of children who have been exposed to potentially harmful environmental conditions for two years.  Testing should be done before occupancy.

If the council bows to this special interest group by upholding the use variance, the township could be placed in legal jeopardy.  Who will be responsible if a child is run over by a truck or becomes ill from adverse environmental conditions?

Nona Henderson

Follow Patch on Facebook. Visit www.facebook.com/EastBrunswickPatch and like us. You can also find us on Twitter at twitter.com/EBrunswickPatch.

Kelly January 09, 2013 at 09:13 PM
I see no attacks on teachers at all. I feel bad for Hatikvah teachers that have no experienced educators there to mentor them. They deserve, as any other professionals, the opportunity to hone their craft with qualified mentors. Perhaps, if they had that students wouldn't be mistreated and taped without parental consent or left in a bathroom at the school. It's possible that experienced educators could have dealt with the situation appropriately.
EBtalloaks January 10, 2013 at 05:30 AM
Kelly and 111375 - The years of experience on the website provided by 111375 only reflects years teaching in New Jersey public schools (or some related criteria). I happen to know that some of those teachers showing just a few years of experience actually have 10+ years of overall teaching experience encompassing schools in other states, private schools, etc. There is no lack of experienced teachers at Hatikvah.
EBtalloaks January 10, 2013 at 02:45 PM
From Experience - It is incredibly distasteful and disrespectful of someone's privacy to mention a former teacher by name on this public forum. You should delete your post immediately.
From Experience January 10, 2013 at 03:32 PM
Maybe the school should set the tone by respecting children's privacy. Getting rid of a principal may have helped, but it doesn't turn back time.
EBtalloaks January 10, 2013 at 03:47 PM
From Experience - I'm not in your shoes and you're entitled to your opinions and perspectives. In fact, I'm genuinely interested in hearing both sides of the issues that are being discussed here. But I strongly encourage you to leave individual names off public forums and delete your post. Unless a specific teacher, principal, administrator, etc. called you out by name on a Patch forum, he or she has no business being done so by you.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »