Politics & Government

Democrats Giving Christie Three 'Tax Cuts' -- Just Not the One He Wants

Senate, Assembly committees to vote today on budget, millionaire's tax, Earned Income Tax Credit.

For Gov. Chris Christie, it must be like a bad horror movie. Earlier this week, he likened Democrats to vampires -- recalcitrant ones who won't stay dead despite the stakes through their hearts. Now he may be facing an even more fiendish foe: zombie Democrats called back to life after years of acquiescing to the governor's agenda.    

After a week of caucuses, phone calls and behind-the-scenes cajoling, the Senate and Assembly budget committees today are expected to call the governor’s bluff on his threat to veto any budget that did not include an immediate tax cut -- a threat that implicitly carries with it the possibility of a government shutdown July 1.

To Christie’s chagrin, the Democratic-controlled committees today are expected to approve a third version of the “millionaire’s tax” that he has already vetoed twice and an expansion of the Earned Income Tax Cut for the working poor.

Find out what's happening in East Brunswickwith free, real-time updates from Patch.

But the Democratic panels will refuse to pass a bill appropriating the $183 million he has set aside in the budget for an income tax cut the governor has been campaigning for in New Jersey town hall meetings and at Republican events and fundraisers coast-to-coast since January.

Democratic legislative leaders insist it is fiscally responsible to put the $183 million earmarked for a tax cut into a special surplus fund dedicated to property tax relief that would only be allocated if the Christie administration hit its revenue projections for the upcoming budget year. Democrats consider this unlikely after three consecutive months in which revenues came in below projections and Treasurer Andrew Sidamon-Eristoff was forced to come up with $672 million in one-shot revenues and other maneuvers to rebalance the Fiscal Year 2012 and 2013 budgets.

Find out what's happening in East Brunswickwith free, real-time updates from Patch.

Senate Budget Committee Chairman Paul Sarlo (D-Bergen) reiterated that the Legislature is sending Christie a $32 billion budget only because he refuses to negotiate his 7.3 percent revenue growth projection, which is not only the highest in the nation, but three times the national average.

Overly Optimistic

“I want to make it clear that we still recognize that these are very overly optimistic numbers,” Sarlo said. “But ultimately, this governor is going to have to live and die by these revenues. He’s going to own this July 1 . . . Ultimately, if the revenues don’t come in as he’s projecting, he’s going to have to come back to us with spending cuts in the near future.”

Spending cuts, Sarlo said -- not requests to appropriate the $183 million set aside for tax cuts. If David Rosen, budget director for the nonpartisan Office of Legislative Services, is right, Christie’s revenue projections will be off by $724 million to $824 million – which will not only eat up the state’s skimpy $300 million surplus, but the $183 million set aside for tax cuts as well.

Christie, who last month called Rosen the “Doctor Kevorkian of the numbers” for daring to lay out revenue numbers that threatened to kill his tax cut, compared Sarlo and other Democratic leaders to vampires in making it clear that the Democratic budget plan would be dead on arrival.

Corzine Vampires

“The last couple of weeks we’ve seen an ugly type of Democrat rear its head again,” Christie said, stalking back and forth animatedly at a Cedar Grove Town Hall meeting Tuesday. “I think you thought you had slayed this type of Democrat in 2009, that you had taken the wooden stake and put it through this kind of Democrats’ heart."

“Two and a half years into my term, you thought the Corzine Democrats were dead and they’re back. They’re back and they’re going to tell you now over the next 12 days, we’ll put money in the budget for a tax cut and we’ll give it to you in January . . . They say, ‘Trust us, trust us.’”

For Democrats, however, it’s about not trusting Christie, and about the fear that his “New Jersey Comeback” will prove to be the “New Jersey Setback,” as Assembly Budget Committee Chair Vincent Prieto (D-Hudson) put it. His concern is that this spring’s lagging revenue numbers indicate that New Jersey’s economy continues to sputter, as it did last year when the state’s Gross Domestic Product actually shrank 0.5 percent.

Senate and Assembly Democrats were divided over the millionaire’s tax a week ago. Assembly Democrats were determined to push Assembly Majority Leader Lou Greenwald’s plan to increase the top tax bracket on the state’s 16,000 millionaires from 8.97 percent to 10.75 percent. That would raise $789 million to fund an additional $1,000 property tax credit for senior citizens making up to $150,000 and non-seniors up to $75,000.

The Senate, however, was split over whether to send Christie yet another millionaire’s tax to veto. Senate President Stephen Sweeney (D-Gloucester), had originally decided not to include a millionaire’s tax in his plan to offer property tax credits up to $1,000 for those earning up to $250,000, and his plan was praised -- and ultimately endorsed -- by Christie until it, too, sank under the weight of the terrible April revenue numbers.

By Wednesday, however, the Senate was on board with the millionaire’s tax, as Greenwald had predicted last week.

Continue reading on NJSpotlight.com

NJ Spotlight is an online news service providing insight and information on issues critical to New Jersey.


Get more local news delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for free Patch newsletters and alerts.

We’ve removed the ability to reply as we work to make improvements. Learn more here